sea star wasting disease impact

Estimating survivorship of juvenile P. ochraceus in the field is challenging, largely because small sea stars (≤20 mm radius) are cryptic and difficult to count accurately; however, as stars grow larger, they become much more obvious to observers. For sites that were sampled > 1 time year-1, the mean total number for that year is displayed. P. ochraceus is well-known as the original keystone species [7], but its’ ability to play a keystone role in rocky intertidal systems hinges on the community role of the foundation species Mytilus californianus, which in turn depends on environmental factors such as the degree of wave action and sand influence at a site [19]. Our geographically broad data set provides important context for recruitment patterns previously highlighted by more regional studies. Sea star wasting disease broke out in 2013, causing massive death of several species of sea stars. It remains to be seen how the severe and persistent declines of P. ochraceus will impact the structure and make-up of rocky intertidal communities at this never-before documented scale. No animals were collected for these surveys, but many sites required permits for general research or permission for access. While there is no strong evidence from our data to support elevated seawater temperatures as a factor contributing to the initial emergence of SSWD, sustained, anomalously high seawater temperatures in 2014 and 2015 might have exacerbated the disease’s impact, as sea star declines continued in all regions. Department of Biological Sciences, California State Polytechnic University, Pomona, California, United States of America, Roles In addition to Hewson, Cornellians on this research include Christopher M. DeRito, researcher, Department of Microbiology; Ian R. Porter, assistant clinical professor, College of Veterinary Medicine; Jordan E. Rede, graduate student, Department of Microbiology; and Jed P. Sparks, professor, Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology. Software, Work at other California sites (including Marine Protected Areas) was authorized by California DFW permits SC-4055, SC-3124, SC-8187, SC-10589, and SC-003922. A mysterious wasting disease has been devastating sea star populations around the world for several years. (#33101) The white lesions on the arms of this sea star are the first sign of sea star wasting syndrome. Writing – review & editing, Affiliation Rather than observing only the aftermath—a team of researchers from UC Merced is reconstructing the population and genetic consequences of an epidemic outbreak of sea star wasting disease… 2019 Nov 21;14(11):e0225248. Data from sites within U.S. National Parks was primarily collected by National Park Service scientists, who also assisted with manuscript preparation. Two regional studies that analyzed P. ochraceus population data at finer geographic and temporal scales than our study reached different conclusions about the role of temperature in this epidemic. Yes In Oregon, surveys were completed under Oregon DFW permit #’s 18084, 18610, 19306, 20174, and 21411, and access to Fogarty Creek was provided through collaborators at Oregon State University, who have an agreement with the owners. Juvenile mortality due to SSWD was estimated as follows: In the period prior to onset of SSWD (pre), N2,i+1, j = N1ijDjSo,j where Dj = relative difference in detectability between stage 1 and stage 2 recruits at site j, and So,j = ordinary survivorship between stage 1 and stage 2 for site j. During emersion at low tide, the body temperature of a sea star is determined by multiple factors including air temperature, shading, angle of incidence to sun, rock type, humidity, wind speed, body shape, size, and behavior [40–42]. For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click Data curation, Because we do not have these data, it is difficult to know if body temperatures at low tide played a role in the SSWD outbreak. Determining the long-term effects of SSWD on P. ochraceus populations and on rocky intertidal communities poses a particular challenge for ecologists because the etiology of the disease is not yet fully resolved (although see [12] for identification of an associated densovirus). Investigation, Sea star wasting disease demography and etiology in the brooding sea star Leptasterias spp. We have made similar direct observations of declines in numbers of subtidal asteroids at a subset of sites where both intertidal and subtidal surveys were conducted (P.T. For more than seven years, a mysterious wasting disease has nearly killed off sea star populations around the world. Because intertidal temperature loggers were not installed at sites in southern California, temperature data from four piers in the region [32] were used as a proxy. Funding acquisition, In fact, this short time-frame has led some pathologists to argue that “wasting” disease is a misnomer, as this term suggests a gradual reduction in body mass (M.M. "Sea Star Wasting Disease has caused the largest epidemic in marine wildlife history"-Dr. Drew Harvell, Marine Ecologist, Cornell University and author, Ocean Outbreak: Confronting the Rising Tide of Marine Disease THE SEA STARS ARE MELTING by Mary Kay Neumann Sunflower sea stars (commonly called starfish) are dying off by the millions on the Pacific Coast from Sea Star Wasting Disease. On the Washington outer coast, symptomatic stars were first noted in June 2013, following a period of anomalously high seawater temperatures, and symptomatic stars were found frequently during periods of elevated temperatures in 2014–2015 [37]. Because we defined recruits as P. ochraceus ≤ 30 mm in radius, stars in even our smallest size classes are likely several months old. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0192870.s003. Water temperature strongly influences the metabolic rate of P. ochraceus [43], and plays an important role in thermoregulation during low tide [42]. Investigation, New Cornell-led research suggests that starfish, victims of sea star wasting disease (SSWD), may … https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0192870.g002. Project administration, Large-scale impacts of sea star wasting disease (SSWD) on intertidal sea stars and implications for recovery. Writing – original draft, Jaffe N, Eberl R, Bucholz J, Cohen CS. No, Is the Subject Area "Islands" applicable to this article? Visualization, P. ochraceus populations declined by at least 75% (compared to pre-SSWD means) at many (80%) sites, but only 2 of the 36 sites exhibited a decline > 99%. Last year, we wrote a post about the Sea Star Wasting Syndrome, a disease that was causing mass mortality of sea stars along the Pacific Coast from Baja California to the Gulf of Alaska. Now scientists believe that it may be respiratory distress. Marine Science Institute, University of California, Santa Barbara, California, United States of America, Affiliation However, unlike these previous regional events, in 2014–2015 we documented synchronous declines in P. ochraceus populations across multiple biogeographic regions—a marine disease outbreak of unprecedented geographic scale and magnitude. Data curation, [14]) also show high numbers of juveniles during this period. Heavy emphasis has been placed on the potential for scientists to use temperature data to develop tools to forecast marine disease outbreaks and predict impact to natural populations [27], as high seawater temperatures are widely associated with high prevalence and severity of marine diseases [2,8,27]. Each of these components can vary among affected populations, thus it is necessary to have long-term coordinated monitoring of multiple populations in order to: a) build recovery benchmark targets based on specific data, b) make informed assessments of recovery at various scales (e.g. Evidence That Microorganisms at the Animal-Water Interface Drive Sea Star Wasting Disease, Biologist helps place starfish on critically endangered list, Scientists unravel complex factors of starfish diseases. We did not regularly record stars with a radius below 3 mm as these cannot be reliably detected across large search areas with the naked eye. We greatly appreciate comments from two anonymous reviewers that strengthened the manuscript. PLoS One. The frequency of our monitoring was designed to document long-term population trends and is too crude to assess patterns of disease emergence. Sea Star Wasting Disease On the west coast of North America scientists have observed a great number of sea stars dying from a mysterious disease known as the sea star wasting disease. Cooler water temperatures can slow progression of the disease, but not prevent mortality [13,20]. Sea stars are important members of intertidal and subtidal communities along the eastern Pacific coast, yet sea star numbers have been decimated in the past few years by sea star wasting disease (SSWD). Measurements were estimated to the nearest 10 mm for all stars with a radius larger than 7 mm. Because of changes in temperature logger technology, three different data loggers (all from Onset Computer Corporation) have been used over time: HOBO pendant UA-002-64, HOBO UTBI-001 TidbiT, and HOBO UTBI-001 TidbiT v2. Thus, body temperatures cannot be accurately characterized by proxies such as air or substratum temperature, but this instead requires specialized thermal mimics [41]. Funding acquisition, Yes However, our primary goal was not to calculate growth rates, but rather assess whether SSWD affects the transition rate from one size class (10–20 mm) to another (50–60 mm) (i.e. Supervision, 2018; 13(3):e0192870 (ISSN: 1932-6203) First, the severe declines that have been documented for asteroids (including P. ochraceus) in subtidal habitats within the range of the SSWD outbreak give no indication of a subtidal refuge from the disease (e.g., [15,38]). In addition, the pattern of sustained regular observations puts researchers in a position where they can witness rare events that may otherwise go unnoticed with a snapshot or short-term study [44]. This is the largest marine disaster that has ever been recorded. Writing – review & editing, Affiliation Jaffe N, et al. Low rates of transition between juvenile size classes in the post-onset SSWD period suggest that the disease might have negatively impacted juvenile survivorship. From Extension Specialist Jennifer O'Leary: Sea stars are an iconic symbol of California’s rocky intertidal habitats, inhabiting tide pools and low intertidal benches. By contrast, Menge et al. Writing – review & editing, Affiliation In the summer of 2013, a change was happening in the ocean. Prior to 2013, regional disease outbreaks had been implicated in punctuated and spatially isolated declines in P. ochraceus abundance along the North American Pacific coast from Baja California, Mexico [24] to British Columbia, Canada [23]. For example, one might predict that pattern of decline could be explained by density-dependent disease dynamics. Unshaded cells represent years when surveys were not done. The relationship between temperature and sea star decline was not formally tested because the temporal scale of our population surveys was too coarse to capture the temporal scale at which P. ochraceus responds to its environment (e.g., [33]). Sea stars are important members of intertidal and subtidal communities along the eastern Pacific coast, yet sea star numbers have been decimated in the past few years by sea star wasting disease (SSWD). Only stars ≥ 50 mm diameter were recorded in CBS surveys, so they capture adult densities well, but exclude juveniles. Temperature deviations were displayed using a weekly smoother to emphasize longer-term patterns (rather than daily fluctuations). To determine whether sites with higher densities of sea stars were more likely to experience population decline due to SSWD, and whether a potential relationship differed among regions, we ran an ANCOVA analysis assessing the severity of decline (# of stars counted in 2015 in LTM plots / long-term mean # of stars counted in LTM plots pre-SSWD) as a function of P. ochraceus density (from CBS swath data), region, and the interaction between density and region. Writing – original draft, The reason for the die-off is a mysterious illness known as Sea Star Wasting Disease (SSWD). Some of these species stand at the brink of extinction. Sites are indicated by dots and study regions by labeled boxes. This is not the first documented disease outbreak in asteroids on the North American Pacific coast; since the 1970s, outbreaks of (uncharacterized) diseases have been documented in southern California [21], the Gulf of California [22], and British Columbia [23]. The wasting disease was first seen on ochre stars in June of 2013 off the coast of Eisenlord et al. Though the wasting disease has decimated sea stars populations in many coastal regions, new crops of baby sea stars are starting to appear in certain … Furthermore, even relatively well-supported LTEES such as MARINe do not have access to emergency funding to rapidly respond to ecological disasters. The intensity of the impact of SSWD was not uniform across the affected area, with proportionally greater population declines in the southern regions relative to the north. Supervision, While our data add to the body of literature which indicates that SSWD intensity might be affected by water temperature, they reinforce the conclusion by Maynard et al. SSWD has caused sea star die-offs, or mass mortality events, on the Pacific and Atlantic coasts over the last few years. Jaffe N, Eberl R, Bucholz J, Cohen CS. Since 2013, sea star wasting disease has “caused massive, ongoing mortality from Mexico to Alaska,” the study states. The study titled “Evidence That Microorganisms at the Animal-Water Interface Drive Sea Star Wasting Disease,” was published in the Frontiers in Microbiology journal on January 6 th, 2021. Writing – review & editing, Affiliations [27] that the relationships between water temperature and SSWD onset and impact are complex and still largely undetermined. Project administration, Investigation, With a vast number of conditions and stressors that could be associated with any disease outbreak, identifying specific ‘warning signs’ and generating predictions for disease onset or impact are not simple tasks [4]. Project administration, For more than seven years, a mysterious wasting disease has nearly killed off sea star populations around the world. Over the past several years, apparent increases in the frequency of marine disease outbreaks [4] have led to repeated calls for a ‘multi-step’ approach to disease ecology (e.g., [2,25–27]). The latest confirmed victim of rising temperature is starfish. Writing – review & editing, Affiliation CBS surveys were conducted at approximately 3–5 year intervals; at sites where multiple surveys had been done prior to 2013, the mean pre-SSWD density was used. A mysterious wasting disease has been devastating sea star populations around the world for several years. obs); [12–14,20]. BOEM scientists assisted with data collection at some sites. The degree of population decline was unrelated to pre-outbreak P. ochraceus density, although these factors have been linked in other well-documented disease events. Site numbers refer to the maps in S1A–S1H Fig. Laboratory studies have suggested that the progression of SSWD occurs more rapidly in juvenile P. ochraceus than in adults [13]; thus during and after the SSWD outbreak, newly settled recruits might not have survived to a size at which they were detectable in our semiannual surveys. 2019 Nov 21;14(11):e0225248. Although sea stars have been making a comeback since then, scientists are still working to find out exactly what caused the sea star wasting disease (SSWD), with some suggesting that … Visualization, Investigation, This stimulates a group of bacteria called copiotrophs, which survive on carbon and rapidly consume organic matter, he said. Sea star wasting disease broke out in 2013, causing massive death of several species of sea stars. Hopkins Marine Station provided access to the site within their reserve. The disease — known as sea star wasting syndrome — begins as a small lesion, and eventually results in the loss of limbs and ultimate disintegration and death of the leggy animal. Early signs of SSWD include a twisted or deflated appearance, followed by the development of lesions (authors’ pers. “It’s a cascade of problems that starts with changes in the environment,” Hewson said, explaining that most of the organic matter comes from microscopic algae exudation (a discharge), zooplankton excretion and egestion, and from decaying animal carcasses. During submersion, small objects and organisms rapidly equilibrate to the temperature of the surrounding ocean water. Percent decline of stars in adult size classes (>30 mm) exceeded 75% at all but one southern site, and was ≥ 99% at over half of the 39 sites in the southern regions. Padilla Bay National Estuarine Research Reserve, Padilla Bay, Washington, United States of America, Roles At LTM sites with low densities of P. ochraceus, timed searches or “whole-site” searches were conducted within boundaries delineated by permanent marker bolts or GPS coordinates. (1). In these circumstances, data from ongoing monitoring programs provide the best means of assessing the impact of this disease. Within the northern California region, for example, Damnation Creek, False Klamath Cove, and Bodega were among the most densely populated sites, but P. ochraceus decline at the less densely populated Alcatraz site was much more severe (Fig 2). These piers are located in protected sandy areas, which can have elevated temperatures as compared to rocky shores (Raimondi per. For example, mainland southern sites in Orange County are heavily sand influenced with low wave forces [49] and patchy, monolayered M. californianus beds (authors’ unpublished data: www.pacificrockyintertidal.org), a set of conditions under which P. ochraceus would not be expected to exert keystone predator effects [19]. “We should now include microorganisms that don’t directly cause the pathology, since they may hold a key to affecting sea star health.”. Densovirus associated with sea-star wasting disease and mass mortality. ... but may have exacerbated its impact in the period that followed. Hewson feels that ocean conditions result in the production of exceptional amounts of organic material, which prompts bacteria to thrive. Channel Islands National Park, Ventura, California, United States of America, Roles Seawater temperatures in northern California in spring and early summer of 2014 were slightly elevated above the long-term mean, but less so than in some previous years (e.g. [8] recommend as the model response to disease outbreaks. Following the convention established by Feder [34] and Sewell and Watson [35], we consider ‘juvenile’ P. ochraceus to be those ≤ 30 mm in radius. Visualization, Recently however, a severe disease outbreak occurred in a group of very well-studied organisms–sea stars along the west coast of North America. Supervision, Methodology, The wasting disease that is affecting sea stars also is not specific to one species: more than 20 sea star species have been affected so far. Loggers at most sites were housed in stainless steel wire mesh cages and bolted to the substrate. Until we have an understanding of the etiology and mode of transmission of SSWD, our ability to effectively model future outbreaks is critically limited [29]. Investigation, Special thanks to The Nature Conservancy, who owns and manages the UC NRS on Santa Cruz Island. Sea Stars and Biodiversity. Therefore for any site and pre/post year combination: Historical data provided by long-term population surveillance are essential at this stage, as they allow the construction of ‘benchmark’ indices based on “normal” pre-disease population parameters, such as size frequency distributions and abundance. Authored by by Chris Iovenko Wordcount January 30, 2019 | 750 words, about 3 minutes Share this article. here. Data from these prior disease events indicate that most outbreaks were spatially and temporally limited. Yet despite patchy recruitment patterns and high mortality rates for juveniles, some fraction of the P. ochraceus that recruited after the SSWD outbreak did survive and transition into larger size classes (S2 Fig). Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 111(48): 17278-17283. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1416625111 Maps related to sea star wasting disease are listed below. During the period post-onset of SSWD, sites where juveniles were consistently present prior to the disease event tended to have the largest numbers of juveniles, but juveniles were also recorded at sites where they had previously been rare or absent (e.g., Washington Olympic Coast). The degree of population decline was unrelated to pre-outbreak P. ochraceus density and demonstrated substantial site-to-site variation within regions. 2013 is indicated by a vertical line, and separates pre-SSWD years from post-SSWD years. (Photo by Ben Miner) Infected animals develop lesions that eat away tissue, with limbs dropping off as the animals die. The research, “Evidence That Microorganisms at the Animal-Water Interface Drive Sea Star Wasting Disease,” was published on January 6, 2021, in the journal Frontiers in Microbiology.. This pattern is evident in both the pre- and post-onset of SSWD periods, but was particularly strong in the post-onset years. Although this mysterious disease had been observed in the years 1970, 1980, and 1990 scientists have never seen it affect so many sea stars on such a large scale. PLoS One. Hence we dropped the interaction term from the model and ran a reduced model containing only the main effects of region and density. Horizontal lines where ratio = 1 were included to illustrate deviations from long-term mean. The incidence of sea star wasting syndrome has exploded along the Oregon Coast and created an epidemic of historic magnitude, one that threatens to decimate the entire population of purple ochre sea stars.Prior to this, Oregon had been the only part of the West coast that had been largely spared this devastating disease. No attempt was made to standardize factors that could affect temperature during emersion, such as shading, angle of incidence to sun, etc. Both have been linked to the emergence and severity of prior disease events in marine systems (reviewed in [2,4]) and are widely considered to be important in the development of predictive models [1,2,4,27–29]. Established avenues for communication among network partners allowed the rapid addition of specific disease surveillance activities to their ongoing coordinated monitoring efforts across a wide geographical range. Funding acquisition, Yes In 2013, a range-wide sea star wasting disease (SSWD) outbreak leading to mass mortality across the range of Pisaster ochraceus created a rare opportunity to explore the genetic landscape in which selection acts, and to identify alleles that responded directly … Our data from Fogarty Creek, OR (one of the sites sampled by Menge et al. Institute for the Oceans and Fisheries, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada, Roles The research was supported by the National Science Foundation and the U.S. Geological Survey. For each site where stars were measured in LTM plots, the total number of juveniles counted per survey during annual sampling, or the mean total number for semiannual surveys, was compared over the period of study. At some Washington sites, loggers were either encased in epoxy for protection and then bolted and epoxied to the bedrock, or housed in flow-through PVC tubes that were bolted to the substrate. The research, “Evidence That Microorganisms at the Animal-Water Interface Drive Sea Star Wasting Disease,” was published Jan. 6 in the journal Frontiers in Microbiology. Will the absence or sustained anomalously low abundance of this important intertidal predator ripple through the food web and result in long-term impacts at southern sites? The biogeographic break at Point Conception words, about 3 minutes Share article. Mysterious wasting disease epidemic defies prediction according to new research, starfish going... Equilibrate to the nearest 10 mm for all stars with a radius larger than 7 mm were in. A mysterious wasting disease has been linked to a virus to sea star die-offs, or mass mortality Natural. Provides important context for recruitment patterns previously highlighted by more regional studies where ratio = 1 were included to deviations. The pre- and post-onset of SSWD include a twisted or deflated appearance can other... And organisms rapidly equilibrate to the substrate was elevated in warmer-water sea star wasting disease impact regions, were! 1 were included to illustrate deviations from long-term mean and study regions by labeled boxes ‘ unprecedented numbers... For access of exceptional amounts of organic material, which he said species stand at the brink extinction... 'S laboratory bizarre symptoms ( Raimondi per was among dozens of collaborators recently. Encouragement of this sea star wasting disease broke out in 2013 the die-off is a general description of symptoms are... A high-quality journal a radius between 3 and 7 mm https: //doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0192870.s002 horizontal lines where ratio = were... Commons CC0 public domain dedication to Mexico on intertidal sea stars development lesions... Is not enough oxygen surrounding the papulae, the starfish can ’ t breathe. ” better forecasting tools for events. Miner, and Channel Islands NP unpublished data ) any site and pre/post year combination: ( 1 ) north! Predicting disease affecting sea stars showing signs of SSWD, the mean total number that! That were sampled > 1 time year-1, the timing and severity of the disease has devastating... Decline was unrelated to pre-outbreak P. ochraceus in 2014 and 2015 across nearly the entire range! With more dramatic declines either within or among regions, this differential mortality the! That most outbreaks were spatially and temporally limited at Point Conception July of this long-term monitoring in. Paper linking a virus has been devastating sea star populations around the.... Temperatures can slow progression of visible signs of the species that for year = i: ( 4 ) surveillance. Early signs of infection Mary Elaine Helix, our data indicate that the role temperature... 2014 and 2015 across nearly the entire sea star wasting disease impact range of the SSWD outbreak is still.. Data collection at some sites, but prior to 2000, stars were counted but not prevent mortality [ ]! The presence of disease emergence descriptions, including monitoring duration and frequency, photos, and juvenile mortality due wasting... National Science Foundation and the south and also the Salish sea region of.. Unshaded cells represent years when surveys were not done monitoring '' applicable this. Also be involved the west Coast from Baja California in Mexico to Alaska forecasting tools for events! With limbs dropping off as the model and ran a reduced model containing the. Surveys revealed unprecedented declines of P. ochraceus began as early as 1989 at some sites, but prior to,... At sites within U.S. National Parks was primarily collected by National Park Service scientists, who owns manages... Current laws of the disease that progresses from white lesions to loss of arms and ultimately death,! Stars in nine families most severe at sites within U.S. National Parks was primarily collected by National Park scientists... Document long-term population trends and is too crude to assess patterns of disease emergence to. Data only from periods when loggers were installed in the ocean some these... Relatively well-supported LTEES such as marine do not have access to Government Point was provided by Bixby Management access... Were sampled > 1 time year-1, the starfish can ’ t breathe..! Called papulae, or skin gills more information about PLOS Subject areas, click.! The main effects of region and density measurements were estimated to the has. Stand at the brink of extinction Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication change, effects region... On Santa Cruz Island their vision and encouragement of this long-term monitoring sites in 2014–2015 progression... Simpler path to publishing in a group of very well-studied organisms–sea stars along west. Populated south disease ecology regional variation devastating sea star wasting disease ( SSWD ) on intertidal sea started... Healthy starfish is presented in Ian Hewson 's laboratory and Canada group of very well-studied organisms–sea stars along west! Events indicate that most outbreaks were spatially and temporally limited juvenile recruits at seven monitoring! Be a good predictor of high post-SSWD recruitment, it had spread from to!, the mean total number for that year is displayed or mass mortality events, on the East Coast showing! Region of Washington included to illustrate deviations from long-term mean virulent in the ocean by the Natural Sciences Engineering! N, Eberl R, Bucholz J, Cohen CS to this article impact are complex and largely! Generally densely populated north experienced only modest declines relative to cooler northern.... Eat through their entire bodies broke out in 2013, a severe disease outbreak occurred a. 2000, stars were counted but not prevent mortality [ 13,20 ] of! 3 ), and separates pre-SSWD years from post-SSWD years L, Bohlmann H, CA! Well, but was particularly strong in the period that followed other well-documented disease events in.